Being accused of first‑degree murder under California Penal Code § 189 is one of the most serious legal situations someone can face. Understanding what a first degree murder sentence California might involve is crucial—not just the length of time someone might serve, but also what kinds of sentences are possible, what special circumstances may make things worse, and what defenses are available. David P. Shapiro Criminal Defense Attorneys provide clarity for clients throughout Southern California on these high‑stakes cases.
What Qualifies as First‑Degree Murder under PC § 189
California law makes a distinction between first‑degree murder and second‑degree murder under Penal Code § 189. First‑degree murder includes killings that are willful, deliberate, and premeditated, or murders that fall into certain categories even without those mental state elements. Some of the key ways a killing is considered first‑degree under § 189 include:
- Using poison, lying in wait, torture, or explosives.
- Committing murder in the commission of certain felonies (felony murder rule) such as burglary, robbery, arson, kidnapping, mayhem, and certain sexual crimes.
- Discharging a firearm from a motor vehicle with the intent to kill, when the victim is outside.
The law sets high evidence burdens: prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant acted with malice aforethought, and that the killing falls into one of the specified categories under § 189. Mrs. Shapiro’s firm often helps defendants understand whether the prosecution’s evidence meets those thresholds.
What “First‑Degree Murder Sentence California” Looks Like
Sentencing for first‑degree murder in California depends on whether “special circumstances” apply. Below is a breakdown of what the sentences often are:
| Scenario | Typical Sentence |
| First‑degree murder without special circumstances | Life imprisonment with the possibility of parole. Usually starts at 25 years to life. |
| First‑degree murder with special circumstances | Life without the possibility of parole (LWOP) or, in very rare cases (with capital penalty sought and allowed) the death penalty. However, note that while the law allows for the death penalty, California has a moratorium on executions as of 2019. |
Special circumstances under California PC § 190.2 (and related sections) include things like multiple victims, murder for financial gain, killing of a peace officer, killing committed during commission of certain felonies with aggravating behavior (torture, lying‑in‑wait, etc.), and other particularly heinous and cruel factors.
What Special Circumstances Mean in Practice
Special circumstances drastically change exposure:
- If found guilty of first‑degree murder with one or more special circumstances, the defendant may never be eligible for parole, i.e. LWOP.
- The death penalty remains a possible sentence under California law, but because of the moratorium on executions, it’s rarely enforced.
So, someone convicted under first‑degree murder under PC 189 could face either:
- A minimum of 25 years to life (parole possible)
- Life without parole (for special circumstances)
- Or, theoretically, death penalty (though it’s not being carried out under current policy).
Factors That Influence the Sentence Severity
Even within the framework above, several additional variables can influence exactly how harsh the sentence will be:
- Nature of the Crime / Method
- Was there lying‑in‑wait, torture, or use of poison?
- Was it a drive‑by shooting? Use of a destructive device or weapon of mass destruction? These enhance culpability.
- Was there lying‑in‑wait, torture, or use of poison?
- Defendant’s Role in Felony Murder Cases
- Under Senate Bill 1437 (2018) modifications, not everyone involved in an underlying felony that leads to a death is automatically guilty of first‑degree murder. The defendant must be the actual killer, or have intended to kill, or been a major participant acting with reckless indifference.
- Under Senate Bill 1437 (2018) modifications, not everyone involved in an underlying felony that leads to a death is automatically guilty of first‑degree murder. The defendant must be the actual killer, or have intended to kill, or been a major participant acting with reckless indifference.
- Criminal History
- Prior convictions, especially for violent crimes, can lead prosecutors or courts to seek more severe punishment.
- Prior convictions, especially for violent crimes, can lead prosecutors or courts to seek more severe punishment.
- Aggravating vs. Mitigating Circumstances
- Mitigating evidence (like lack of prior record, youth, mental health issues, provocation) may be argued to reduce severity or to avoid LWOP.
- Mitigating evidence (like lack of prior record, youth, mental health issues, provocation) may be argued to reduce severity or to avoid LWOP.
- Prosecutor Discretion / Jury Decisions
- Whether prosecutors allege special circumstances and whether juries find them to apply (or find credible evidence of premeditation) plays a huge role.
- Whether prosecutors allege special circumstances and whether juries find them to apply (or find credible evidence of premeditation) plays a huge role.
Consequences Beyond Prison Time
Even assuming one avoids LWOP or capital punishment, a first‑degree murder conviction has serious lifelong implications:
- Permanent criminal record with lifelong stigma
- Loss of certain civil rights (voting, firearm ownership, etc.)
- Impact on family, employment, housing, and personal relationships
- Parole conditions for those eligible; strict supervision and limited freedoms
- Potential restitution obligations for financial losses tied to the crime
- For the families of victims, there are legal, emotional, and financial stakes as well
Possible Defenses & Legal Strategies
Because the stakes are so high, strong defense work is vital. Some of the most common defense avenues include:
- Challenging Premeditation or Deliberation: Arguing that the killing was not planned in advance, or didn’t have enough time to qualify as premeditated.
- Felony Murder Defense Under Updated Law: After SB 1437, maybe the defendant doesn’t meet the criteria for felony murder (e.g. wasn’t a major participant or had no intent).
- Challenging Evidence of Special Circumstances: For example, whether torture occurred, whether lying in wait was factual, or whether financial gain was motive.
- Self‑Defense or Justification: If the defendant reasonably believed they faced imminent danger, they may argue self‑defense, though first‑degree murder is harder to defend in those cases.
- Mental Health / Insanity / Diminished Capacity: Under certain conditions, these defenses may reduce charges or influence sentencing.
- Suppression of Evidence: If any evidence was obtained illegally, suppression motions can weaken the prosecution’s case.
What Someone Facing First‑Degree Murder Charges Should Do
If someone is charged under PC § 189, here are steps they should take:
- Secure experienced criminal defense counsel—someone deeply familiar with homicide law, local courts, and capital/special circumstance cases.
- Investigate all angles: evidence of intent, state’s proof of premeditation, whether SB 1437 applies, quality of witness testimony, forensic evidence.
- Understand plea options and whether a plea might reduce risk (e.g. pleading to second‑degree murder under certain conditions).
- Assess whether mitigating factors exist that might influence sentencing.
- Prepare for a long legal process—trial, appeals, sentencing hearings, possible special circumstance findings.
Hiring a Second Degree Murder Charge in San Diego
Because first‑degree murder is among the most serious accusations, having skilled legal counsel like David P. Shapiro Criminal Defense Attorneys can make a major difference. They can:
- Challenge prosecutorial strategy and evidence
- Navigate complex legislation like SB 1437 and special circumstances law
- Advocate for the best possible outcome—whether that’s LWOP avoided, a lesser charge, parole eligibility sooner, or favorable plea terms
When someone searches first degree murder sentence California, they should know: a conviction under PC § 189 can lead to 25 years-to-life in state prison, or life without parole if special circumstances are found. Although the death penalty remains on the books, perpetrators currently face a moratorium on its enforcement.
Correct legal strategy, understanding of the evidence, and strong defense counsel are essential. For more detailed information specific to any case, see the page on first degree murder sentence California from David P. Shapiro Criminal Defense Attorneys. Early, informed action can sometimes change the course of the case.
Experienced SEO Specialist and Web Developer with a strong focus on off-page SEO and guest posting. With 3 years of proven expertise, I help businesses improve their search rankings and build sustainable online presence.
